What I am about to write is probably not going to be received well by all who read it. Please know it’s not written with malice or even a strong sense of aggravation. It’s just really written mostly out of a sense of wanting all of us to be intellectually honest. So, here goes.
First, you need to know a few facts. Number 1 — At FCC we run the sound system at the exact same decibel level every week. It’s the only thing “scientific” that we can measure in our service and know for sure. We do the tests. We know the numbers. Number 2 — No 2 human beings hear sound in the exact same way. Frequencies, pitch, volume all vary from one person to the next. Number 3 — People don’t always hear the same from one week to the next. If someone mowed their grass, went to a concert, caught a ballgame, visited Chicago, or got in a shouting match with their spouse they can have their hearing ability altered temporarily and sometimes permanently.
So, with those facts stated let me share with you what some may not like. On occasion I’m told “the music at FCC is too loud.” At other times I’m told, “So and so was holding their ears during worship.” Usually these comments come from people who have been in the church for a while. Seldom do they come from people who are new to FCC. That might have to do with the spirit of appreciation that flows from people who are experiencing something new and life-changing not something they’ve grown to accept as normal and expected (that’s not the part that might be aggravating by the way).
READ THIS NEXT PARAGRAPH AS A GENERIC EXAMPLE NOT A SPECIFIC CASE! IT’S NOT ABOUT A SPECIFIC SITUATION AS MUCH AS IT’S ABOUT A GENERAL THOUGHT: Recently, it was reported to me that there were people in our morning service who kept their ears covered while the congregation worshipped. Apparently they felt the music that morning was too loud (keep in mind that it is always the same). Then over the weekend we held a concert. The sound techs intentionally ran the music louder (that’s what happens at concerts) than they do on any Sunday morning ever. In fact, statistically the difference in volume was the equivalent difference between sitting in a car with your windows up in downtown Chicago (that’s a normal Sunday volume) versus holding a running chainsaw (that’s at the concert Sunday night). It was later reported, the same folks who had recently covered their ears during worship sat (smiling) throughout an entire 2 hour concert. Then talked about how much they enjoyed it when it was all done. Does that experience make sense to you? I’m not asking, “Do you understand what took place.” I’m asking does it appear consistent to you? It doesn’t to me.
Which then leads me to conclude this: Much of what we hear about sound and volume has very little to do with ears and much more to do with expectation and attitude. (There’s the statement some aren’t going to like.)
April 14, 2008 at 4:51 pm
JP, i think you are right on target with this post!
April 15, 2008 at 7:46 am
JP, I agree with you and thank you for making me check my heart on more than one occasion!
ef
April 15, 2008 at 7:56 am
JP, I too, agree with you. That is why Ehren and I sit up front every week so you are load and in our face. It helps us open our hearts and really prepare ourselves for what you are about to speak to us and we know we need to hear it in one way or another. Thank you.
April 15, 2008 at 4:35 pm
It seems as though people that act in this way must feel something is wrong at a deeper level than volume, but rather than address the real issue, they choose to make a public display of dissent. The ill-feelings that people harbor in their heart over anything, trivial or not, will only hinder their ability to serve God and continually lead them into sin.
While someone may choose to make light of a situation by doing something as silly as covering their ears, the danger is when others start to see this behavior as wise or appropriate and that harbored ill-feeling starts to infect others. I feel like Proverbs 26 speaks caution about similar people, but refers to using words rather than actions. In particular:
24 A malicious man disguises himself with his lips,
but in his heart he harbors deceit.
25 Though his speech is charming, do not believe him,
for seven abominations fill his heart.
26 His malice may be concealed by deception,
but his wickedness will be exposed in the assembly.
27 If a man digs a pit, he will fall into it;
if a man rolls a stone, it will roll back on him.
28 A lying tongue hates those it hurts,
and a flattering mouth works ruin.
April 15, 2008 at 9:16 pm
Way to speak the truth, JP. There is no time for complaining in the church. We all need to be too busy doing God’s work to complain!
April 15, 2008 at 10:06 pm
Very well stated J.P., from a technical stand point. The members of the tech team strive to keep the mix levels at a constant volume using a meter to monitor it. Each persons hearing is different. The variables from week to week, or service to service such as amount of people, where they are seated, even temperature and humidity will cause a change of volume and sound. We try to maintain a constant with all of this.
I know that for me personaly, when I am out in the chairs joining in worship I must close my eyes and try to seperate from the sound and visuals of the stage. To me the time of worship is not about who is on stage, what they are wearing, or what the sound mix is. Worship to me is a time to sing out to the lord to express my love and thankfullness for who GOD is and his grace and love for us.
April 16, 2008 at 4:49 pm
I agree with you, J.P. It really shouldn’t be about loudness, but more about the focus of the singing. Still, it is odd that some people are upset about worship music on Sunday, but any other day of the week it’s no problem. I guess you can’t please everyone all the time.
On a side note, I haven’t been coming to FCC for long, and am used to very traditional worship music, so it was a bit of a culture shock the first time I came to the church. To be honest, I really like the way you guys do the music.
April 16, 2008 at 8:14 pm
JP,
I come from a church, where they do 3 services to keep everyone at the level of volume they are happy with. Everyone worships in a different way, but I completely agree with you about the expectations that people bring to worship with them. The truth is that we are there to glorify the LORD and sing praises to HIM. Therefore the only thing that we should be expecting when walking in to worship is that we will have our hearts and minds and souls opened up to GOD by what we sing and the music we use to express our LOVE for the KING. I truly feel that FCC has struck a great blend of traditional and contemporary music and that the volume level is more than appropriate. I feel that I am able to get lost in the time of worship and forget all things external so that I can focus solely on praising my savior. I really appreciate the worship time at FCC and the impact that it makes on my life throughout the whole week.
April 22, 2008 at 7:58 am
JP you are right on with this, but unfortunately the people that need to hear this the most are those who don’t even know how to work a computer.
May 12, 2008 at 8:17 pm
I just read the blog posts for the first time tonight. They were very interesting, and I went back and read all of them from the beginning.
The one that gave me pause was Ears or Hearts. Personally I love the music at FCC and “too loud” almost never enters my vocabulary at church, at home, or in the car.
However, I was concerned about the condescending tone that some of the reply posts seemed to take. I know several mature people who love and serve God faithfully and are some of the best Christians we can ever hope to meet here on earth. I happen to know that some of these people intentionally come in to the service after the music is over because of the volume.
I can’t explain the specific example JP gave of someone thinking the Sunday music was too loud but enjoying even louder music at a concert. But I can testify that there are some people who legitimately feel the music is too loud and don’t have any other agenda.
Would it be possible to experiment and turn the volume down for a couple of Sundays to see if anyone noticed–see if the “too loud” complaints stopped or if the lower volume caused “too soft” complaints to start?
I’m definitely not always successful, in fact, I probably fail more than I succeed, but I try to live by Jesus words to “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” In this situation that would seem to suggest that we try a softer volume and see what happens.
I’m no sound expert, so maybe a softer volume wouldn’t work. But I am sure that giving it a try would speak volumes of love and caring to those whose ears are legitimately uncomfortable with the current volume.
It is impossible to please everyone, but sometimes it is a great gesture of love to try.
December 31, 2008 at 12:53 am
I have heard a report from one of the mature folks I mentioned in my May 12th posting that the sound quality in church is much improved after the installation of the new sound system.
Thanks!